More than 70 interested citizens attended a discussion on “The Ethics of Stem Cell Research” Sunday evening at Main Street Café & Books in Los Altos.
Moderator Tom Gutshall introduced two notable experts in the field to discuss pros and cons in light of Proposition 71 on the Nov. 2 ballot. The initiative would provide $6 billion (including interest) for stem cell research.
Hank Greely, a professor at Stanford Law School, offered proponents’ side of the stem cell argument, while Jennifer Lahl, director of bioethics and culture and adjunct fellow with the Wilberforce Forum in Washington, D.C., took the opposition arguments.
Lahl said stem cell research is going on now with adult stem cells. Greely responded that embryonic cell research is what proponents are seeking. The embryonic cell creates all kinds of cells that have universal usage unlike the adult cells.
The economic component of Proposition 71 also was debated. Greely said economic activity generated by the initiative would go to universities and research facilities.
Lahl countered with concern that the funding would go toward “speculative research” in what she called “cloning” or creating your own twin and using it as a personal repair kit.
Currently, there are more than 400,000 frozen embryos not for research but for families looking to have children.
Lahl encouraged voters to read arguments both for and against Proposition 71. She reiterated there are ethical issues as well as economic concerns. Greely concluded by asking the audience whether this proposition would make the world better or worse.
The discussion on stem cell research and Proposition 71 will continue next Sunday with a second forum, scheduled 7-9 p.m., at the café. Next week’s speakers will be Dr. Daniel Kraft, Stanford stem cell biologist, and Dr. J. Joseph Prendergast, founder and medical director of Endocrine Therapeutics Inc., a clinic primarily for people with diabetes.
Next Sunday’s discussion will focus on the scientific hopes and concerns embodied in the proposition. Experts disagree on which forms of stem cell research – embryonic, umbilical cord, fetal, or adult stem cell research – would prove the most fruitful.
The forums are hosted by the local group Community Connections at Main Street Cafe & Books, 134 Main St.
